Upper Union Street in Schenectady, NY, is a historic neighborhood known for its charming homes and tree-lined streets. However, recent tree removal projects have sparked controversy among residents. Some argue that the removals are necessary for safety and infrastructure maintenance, while others lament the loss of the neighborhood’s iconic trees. Residents concerned about the tree removals have organized protests and petitioned the city government to reconsider its plans. They argue that the trees provide shade, reduce air pollution, and contribute to the neighborhood’s overall aesthetic appeal. Additionally, they worry that the tree removal will disrupt wildlife and decrease property values. The city has defended its decision to remove the trees, citing concerns about diseased or damaged trees, as well as the need to make way for utility lines and other infrastructure upgrades. The city has also pledged to plant replacement trees in areas where the removals have occurred. However, residents remain skeptical, arguing that the replacement trees will not fully compensate for the loss of the mature trees that have been removed. The controversy over tree removal on Upper Union Street highlights the complex challenges faced by cities as they balance the need for infrastructure improvements with the preservation of their natural resources and the well-being of their residents.